How to Market a Six-Figure Paid Newsletter: A Tactical Guide

 Paid Newsletter: A Tactical Guide

Managing a Paid newsletter is one of the ways to make a decent income online. We’ll explore strategies to attract free subscribers, convert them into paid subscribers, and ultimately build a thriving paid newsletter business. Whether you’re just starting or looking to optimize your current approach, this guide will provide actionable insights to help you succeed.

Understanding the Paid Newsletter Business Model

Before we get into the nitty-gritty, it’s crucial to understand the overall business model and supply chain for a paid newsletter. This model’s first step is writing free content on platforms such as X (formerly Twitter), LinkedIn, Instagram, Facebook, or even Snapchat. The goal here is to generate traffic. This traffic is then funneled into a free newsletter.

The purpose of the free newsletter is twofold:

1. Showcase More Content: It lets you demonstrate to your social media followers that you have more in-depth content.

2. Build an Email List: Getting people onto an email list is essential for educating and incentivizing them to upgrade to your paid newsletter.

Types of Content That Drive Paid Subscriptions: 

When it comes to paid newsletters, the content that typically drives subscriptions falls into two categories:

1. Exclusive Content: This includes data, research, trends, insider stories, and behind-the-scenes content that requires more context and explanation. Due to its short-form nature, this type of content only works well on platforms like Twitter, but it is perfect for a paid newsletter.

2. Expert Content: Consider this as having coffee at scale with someone with decades of experience or unique insights into a specific industry or problem. Subscribers pay to access this level of expertise.

Should Your Free and Paid Newsletters Be Separate?

A common question is whether your free and paid newsletters should be separate. The short answer is that they don’t have to be. Platforms like Substack allow you to organize free and paid issues into a single feed, making it easier for potential subscribers to see what they would get if they upgraded.

Substack is particularly useful because it operates not just as a tool but as a publishing platform with a growing community. The platform has raised significant venture capital, which it uses to build and expand its publishing ecosystem. This investment into the platform often results in additional traffic and discovery, which can benefit your newsletter.

Nearly 20% of paid subscriptions for some newsletters come from Substack’s internal recommendation engine. This means that a significant portion of subscribers discover the newsletter through the platform itself rather than through external social media channels. This kind of built-in discovery is a solid reason to consider using Substack if you’re focused on building a paid newsletter.

Choosing the Right Platform: Substack vs. ConvertKit vs. Beehive

The platform you choose for your paid newsletter will depend on your specific needs:

Substack: Ideal if you want a simple, easy-to-use platform where you can write and paywall some of your content. It’s straightforward and perfect for those who don’t need advanced features.

ConvertKit: This is recommended if you’re looking to build a broader digital products business where your newsletter is the engine. ConvertKit is excellent for collecting emails, upselling products, and creating advanced email funnels like FOMO or abandoned cart sequences.

Beehive: Best suited for building a publication rather than just a paid newsletter. Beehive’s features are more geared towards creating a full-fledged publication, making it a good option if you’re looking to build something similar to a digital magazine.

Publishing Cadence: How Often Should You Publish?

A straightforward publishing cadence for a paid newsletter business is one free and one paid newsletter per week. This cadence serves two essential functions:

1. Marketing Engine: The free newsletter acts as your marketing engine, introducing new readers to your content and driving them towards your paid newsletter.  

2.The Paid Product: The paid newsletter is the actual product you’re selling. As you publish more paid newsletters, the archive grows, increasing the immediate value of your paid subscription. This makes the decision to subscribe easier for potential customers since they’re paying for future content and gaining access to a wealth of past content.

The value of your paid newsletter grows over time, as does the archive, making it an increasingly compelling offer for new subscribers.

Until now, we discussed the importance of understanding your business model, the types of content that drive paid subscriptions, the debate over separating free and paid newsletters, and the best platforms for building your newsletter business. Now, let’s dive into some advanced strategies that can significantly boost your conversion rates and subscriber engagement.

Maximizing Conversions: The Power of Snippets and Strategic Paywalls

One of the most effective strategies for converting free subscribers to paid subscribers is consistently sending them snippets of your paid newsletter. Substack offers a handy feature that allows you to insert a paywall at any point in your newsletter. This feature allows you to share some of your paid content with free subscribers while keeping the most valuable part behind a paywall.

Putting the paywall about 25-30% of the way through each paid newsletter is recommended. This approach ensures that our free subscribers get a taste of the premium content while being reminded that there’s more valuable information available if they upgrade to the paid version. It’s a subtle but powerful reminder that something more substantial is available for those willing to pay.

However, there’s an even more tactical way to implement this strategy. Instead of arbitrarily placing the paywall at 30%, strategically position it at a cliffhanger—before you provide something particularly actionable, like a framework, checklist, or specific guidance. This creates a sense of urgency and FOMO (Fear of Missing Out) among your readers, making them more likely to convert to paying subscribers.

For instance, if your newsletter walks readers through a problem, stop just before you give them the solution. This creates a strong incentive for free subscribers to upgrade, as they’re left wanting more just when you’re about to deliver the most valuable part of the content.

Data shows that newsletters with strategically placed cliffhanger paywalls have a significantly higher conversion rate than those where the paywall is placed randomly. This tactic is an art form that you’ll get better at with practice, but once mastered, it can be a game-changer for your paid newsletter.

Engagement Tactics: Simple Yet Effective CTAs

In addition to your content strategy, another simple yet effective tactic is to include consistent Calls to Action (CTAs) at the end of every newsletter:

– P.S. Can you refer this issue to a friend?

– P.S. Can you gift this paid newsletter to a friend?

– P.S. Please comment with ideas you’d like covered in future issues or share your biggest takeaway from this newsletter.

These CTAs might seem basic, but they serve as important reminders for your readers to engage with your content, whether by referring it to others, giving feedback, or even just thinking about what they’ve learned. People often need a nudge to take action, and these CTAs provide that gentle push.

Including these engagement prompts in every issue helps foster a community around your newsletter, encourages sharing, and increases the likelihood of attracting new subscribers through word-of-mouth.

The Front-End Marketing Engine: Consistency and Focus

Driving traffic to your newsletter can be simple funnels, paid ads, or influencer partnerships. The key is consistency. The entire traffic engine should be revolving around writing short-form posts on platforms like X (formerly Twitter) or LinkedIn. These posts can link to educational email course or paid newsletter, inviting readers to learn more.

You create a steady traffic flow by consistently focusing on the same topic and linking to your newsletter. The quality of your paid newsletter is crucial—it needs to be good enough to make people want to pay. But assuming you’ve nailed that, your marketing efforts should be simple and focused: write about what you know, drive traffic to your newsletter, and remind your audience that your paid content offers even more value.

The Simplicity of Success

Building a six-figure paid newsletter doesn’t require complex strategies or advanced marketing techniques. It’s about understanding your audience’s needs, delivering on that promise with high-quality content, and using well-placed tactics to convert free readers into paying subscribers.

By consistently writing on social media about your topic, driving traffic to your free and paid newsletters, strategically using snippets and paywalls, and including simple CTAs, you can steadily grow your paid subscriber base. Remember, the most successful newsletters aren’t built overnight—they result from repeating effective strategies repeatedly.

Many newsletters use these tactics to build a six-figure annual recurring revenue stream; there’s no secret sauce beyond this. Focus on providing tangible, objective value to your readers, and the rest will follow.

Need to Discuss This?